Florida FreshFood and Drink

Florida’s Unusual Pizzas You Never Knew Existed!

When it comes to culinary creativity, Florida’s unusual pizzas take the spotlight. The Sunshine State is known for its vibrant and diverse food scene, and its pizzas are no exception. From the classic Margherita to the most unconventional toppings, pizza in Florida is a testament to the state’s inventive spirit.

Florida’s pizza scene is as diverse as its ecosystem, offering a wide array of options that cater to every palate. Whether you’re a fan of traditional Italian pies or more adventurous toppings, there’s something for everyone in this southern paradise. But what truly sets apart is its penchant for unusual and creative toppings.

The state’s pizzaiolos aren’t shy about pushing the envelope, experimenting with local ingredients and bold flavors to create unique pies that you won’t find anywhere else. So, if you’re ready to embark on a culinary adventure, let’s delve into the world of Florida’s most unusual pizzas.

The Alligator Sausage Pizza at Evio’s Pizza & Grill

If you’re looking for an authentic Floridian twist on a classic pizza, look no further than Evio’s Pizza & Grill in North Miami Beach. This popular eatery takes the traditional sausage pizza to a whole new level by swapping out pork for alligator meat. Yes, you read that right – alligator! This unique pizza is a culinary adventure that reflects Florida’s rich ecosystem and adventurous spirit.

Evio’s Pizza & Grill is renowned for its innovative menu, which includes a variety of pizzas, gyros, burgers, wings, and salads. But it’s their Alligator Sausage Pizza that truly stands out, offering a taste that’s uniquely Floridian. The alligator meat lends a distinctive flavor to the pizza, making it a must-try for both locals and visitors alike.

Here are some noteworthy aspects that deserve mention:

  • Innovative Menu: Evio’s Pizza & Grill is known for its creative approach to food. Their menu features a blend of traditional dishes and innovative creations, ensuring there’s something for everyone. (Evio’s Pizza)
  • Unique Flavor: The Alligator Sausage Pizza offers a taste that’s uniquely Floridian. The alligator meat, while unusual, adds a distinctive flavor to the pizza that sets it apart from traditional options. (Tripadvisor)

So, if you find yourself in North Miami Beach and are in the mood to try something different, make sure to stop by Evio’s Pizza & Grill and order their Alligator Sausage Pizza. It’s a culinary experience you won’t forget.

The Everglades Pizza at Evan’s Neighborhood Pizza

Venturing further into Florida’s unconventional pizzas, we find ourselves at the now-closed Evan’s Neighborhood Pizza in Fort Myers. This establishment was famous for its “Everglades” pizza—an audacious creation that featured toppings as wild as the local ecosystem. From python to frog legs and even swamp cabbage, this pizza was a culinary representation of Florida’s diverse wildlife.

Evan’s Neighborhood Pizza pushed the boundaries of what could be put on a pizza, reflecting the adventurous spirit of Florida. The Everglades Pizza, named after Florida’s vast national park, was a testament to this ethos. 

Python meat, often compared to chicken but with a slightly more gamey flavor, was the star of the show. Accompanied by frog legs and swamp cabbage, it offered a taste of the Everglades’ unique biodiversity.

Let’s take a closer look at some of the standout features of this infamous pizza:

  • Exotic Toppings: The Everglades Pizza, as reported by HuffPost, was known for its exotic toppings, which included python meat and frog legs. These ingredients added an exciting twist to the traditional pizza, making each bite a surprise.
  • Local Flavor: The LA Times noted the incorporation of elements from the local ecosystem in the Everglades Pizza. This pizza offered a taste of the Everglades, with the inclusion of swamp cabbage, a local delicacy, further emphasizing this connection.
  • Culinary Adventure: According to the Denver Post, the Everglades Pizza was more than just a meal—it was a culinary adventure. It presented customers with an opportunity to explore Florida’s diverse wildlife through their taste buds.
  • Legacy: Despite Evan’s Neighborhood Pizza now being closed, its impact on Florida’s pizza scene is undeniable. As mentioned by the News-Press, the Everglades Pizza will be remembered as a bold culinary experiment that pushed the boundaries of traditional pizza.

Despite its closure, Evan’s Neighborhood Pizza and its daring Everglades Pizza have left an indelible mark on Florida’s culinary landscape. The spirit of innovation and adventure lives on in other eateries across the state, continuing to challenge what we think of as pizza.

The Mac n’ Cheese Pizza at Mellow Mushroom

As we continue our exploration of unique pizzas in Florida, the Mac n’ Cheese Pizza at Mellow Mushroom demands our attention. This pizza is a delightful amalgamation of two comfort foods—macaroni and cheese, and pizza. Imagine sinking your teeth into a slice topped with creamy macaroni, rich cheese, crispy bacon, and crunchy breadcrumbs—it’s a symphony of textures and flavors that will leave you wanting more.

Mellow Mushroom, known for its stone-baked pizzas, has created a masterpiece with this offering. The restaurant chain, with locations throughout Florida and the rest of the U.S., prides itself on using fresh ingredients and providing vegan and gluten-free options. But it’s the Mac n’ Cheese Pizza that steals the show, combining the coziness of macaroni and cheese with the beloved formula of a pizza.

Let’s dig deeper into what makes this pizza so special:

  • Comfort Food Fusion: As highlighted by Mellow Mushroom, the Mac n’ Cheese Pizza is an excellent example of comfort food fusion. The combination of macaroni and cheese atop a pizza crust takes comfort food to another level.
  • Texture Galore: According to reviews on Tripadvisor, the Mac n’ Cheese Pizza offers a mix of textures. The creaminess of the macaroni and cheese pairs beautifully with the crispiness of the bacon and breadcrumbs.
  • Wide Availability: With multiple locations across Florida, as mentioned on their website, Mellow Mushroom makes it easy for pizza lovers to get their hands on this unique creation.
  • Controversy: Not everyone is a fan, though. A YouTube review criticized the Mac n’ Cheese from Mellow Mushroom. However, many customers still swear by the Mac n’ Cheese Pizza, making it a must-try for adventurous foodies.

The Mac n’ Cheese Pizza at Mellow Mushroom is a testament to the innovative spirit of Florida’s pizza scene. Whether you’re a fan of macaroni and cheese, pizza, or both, this unique creation is worth a try.

The Greek Gyro Pizza at Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza

As we journey through Florida’s pizza landscape, our next stop is at Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza in Clearwater. Here, the Italian roots of pizza making are celebrated, yet there’s a certain menu item that takes a detour to the Mediterranean – the Greek Gyro Pizza. This specialty pizza is topped with gyro meat, tzatziki sauce, and fresh veggies, offering a delightful fusion of flavors.

Cristino’s, a family-owned Italian restaurant, specializes in coal-fired pizzas. Their old-world style of baking in a coal oven imparts a unique taste and texture to the pizzas, as briefly mentioned on their website. But it’s their Greek Gyro Pizza that truly stands out, taking customers on a culinary trip from Italy to Greece in a single bite.

Here’s what makes this pizza so distinctive:

  • Mediterranean Flair: The Greek Gyro Pizza, as seen on their menu, brings a Mediterranean twist to the traditional pizza. The combination of gyro meat and tzatziki sauce introduces a new flavor profile, proving that pizza toppings need not be limited to the conventional.
  • Unique Cooking Method: As highlighted by Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza’s About page, the coal oven plays a significant role in the pizza’s allure. The intense heat from the coal oven cooks the pizza in minutes, resulting in a wonderfully crisp crust that perfectly complements the tender gyro meat.
  • Vibrant Atmosphere: According to reviews on Yelp, the restaurant’s ambiance adds to the overall dining experience. The cozy trattoria setting, complete with a verdant patio, enhances the enjoyment of this Greek-inspired pizza.
  • Customer Reception: Despite its unconventional approach, the Greek Gyro Pizza has been warmly received by customers. The fusion of Italian and Greek flavors has made it a popular choice among the restaurant’s diverse offerings.

The Greek Gyro Pizza at Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza is a testament to culinary creativity. It demonstrates how the traditional boundaries of pizza can be expanded, resulting in a delicious and unique creation that resonates with pizza lovers.

The Seafood Pizza at The Garlic

In New Smyrna Beach, Florida, nestled amidst the state’s iconic coastal landscape, sits an Italian restaurant that offers a unique twist on traditional pizza. Known as The Garlic, this eatery is renowned for its Seafood Pizza. Topped with shrimp, scallops, clams, mussels, and calamari, it’s a seafood lover’s dream encased in a pizza crust.

The Garlic is a beloved local institution that brings a taste of Italy to Florida’s shores. Their Seafood Pizza is particularly noteworthy, offering diners an opportunity to enjoy a variety of fresh, locally sourced seafood atop a perfectly baked pizza crust. This dish embodies the restaurant’s commitment to marrying traditional Italian flavors with local ingredients, as detailed on their website.

Following are the specifics of this seafood sensation:

  • Seafood Delight: The Seafood Pizza at The Garlic, as described on their menu, is an oceanic feast. The combination of shrimp, scallops, clams, mussels, and calamari ensures a delightful seafood experience in every bite.
  • Local Ingredients: According to a review on Tripadvisor, The Garlic’s commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients shines through in their Seafood Pizza. The freshness of the seafood complements the tangy pizza sauce and dough beautifully.
  • Unique Dining Experience: As noted by Yelp, the ambiance at The Garlic enhances the overall dining experience. The rustic, Mediterranean-inspired decor sets the perfect backdrop for enjoying their signature Seafood Pizza.
  • Customer Reception: Despite the unconventional toppings, the Seafood Pizza has been well-received by customers. This unique twist on traditional pizza has earned rave reviews and continues to be a crowd favorite, as seen on Yelp.

The Garlic’s Seafood Pizza is a testament to the restaurant’s innovative approach to Italian cuisine. It represents a successful fusion of traditional pizza and fresh, local seafood, making it a must-try for both pizza and seafood enthusiasts alike.

A Delicious Culinary Adventure Through Florida’s Pizza Scene

From quirky combinations to traditional tastes with unique twists, Florida’s pizza scene is a true testament to culinary creativity. The fusion of flavors from around the globe, incorporated into everyone’s favorite Italian staple, makes for an intriguing and delicious journey. 

So, whether you’re a pizza purist or an adventurous foodie, Florida’s pizza restaurants have something delightful in store for you. Who knew a slice of pizza could transport you from Italy to Greece or plunge you into a seafood feast? It’s time to embark on your tasty adventure and discover the unusual pizzas of Florida!

Leave a Reply