Florida Small BusinessTravel Guide

Captain Tony’s Saloon: A Florida Bar Unlike Any Other

Captain Tony’s Saloon, situated in the heart of Key West, Florida, is more than just a bar – it’s a piece of living history with a character all its own. This iconic establishment, named after Anthony “Captain Tony” Tarracino, former mayor and visionary of the city, has become an integral part of the local culture and holds a special place in the hearts of both residents and tourists alike.

From its quirky decor to its legendary tales, this unique watering hole stands out from the crowd. It’s no wonder that Travel Channel featured Captain Tony’s Saloon as one of the most unusual bars in Key West. The saloon’s rich history and vibrant atmosphere are not only captivating but also contribute to its reputation as a must-visit spot in Florida.

So, if you’re looking for a place to grab a drink in Florida that offers more than just your average bar experience, Captain Tony’s Saloon is the place to be. It’s a destination where every visit promises new stories and unforgettable memories, making it a truly unique spot in the Sunshine State’s dining and drinking scene.

The History of Captain Tony’s Saloon

Captain Tony’s Saloon has a history as rich and colorful as the town of Key West itself. The building that now houses this iconic saloon was first constructed in 1851, serving as an ice house and morgue, as detailed in the Saloon History on their official website. This macabre past sets the stage for its later transformation into a unique bar filled with stories and legends.

The bar underwent several transformations until 1958 when it was purchased by a charismatic local charter boat captain named Tony Tarracino, or better known as Captain Tony. According to an article by Old Town Manor, under his ownership, the establishment became a popular spot among locals and tourists alike, earning its reputation as a Key West landmark.

Throughout the years, Captain Tony’s Saloon has been graced by notable visitors, adding to the aura of its fascinating history. As highlighted in an article by 2LaneAmerica, famous personalities like Ernest Hemingway and Jimmy Buffet were known to frequent the bar, contributing to its allure and popularity.

Despite its transformation over the years, the saloon has managed to retain its unique charm and character. Its intriguing past, combined with the lively atmosphere it offers today, makes Captain Tony’s Saloon an enduring symbol of Key West’s vibrant culture and history.

The Unique Atmosphere

The atmosphere of Captain Tony’s Saloon is a unique blend of history, eccentricity, and local charm. This Florida gem has become a beloved landmark due to its distinctive décor and lively ambiance. The moment you step through the door, you’re greeted with an array of memorabilia and local artifacts that tell tales of the past and present.

  • Unique Decor: The walls and ceiling of the saloon are adorned with an eclectic collection of items left by patrons over the years. According to GPSmycity, the bar is filled with license plates, bras, and countless dollar bills, creating a fascinating mosaic of memories.
  • Live Music: As noted by Yelp reviewers, live music is a constant feature at Captain Tony’s Saloon. Local bands and artists keep the atmosphere vibrant, providing a soundtrack that perfectly complements the bar’s quirky vibe.
  • Friendly Service: A common theme among reviews on TripAdvisor is the warm and friendly service at Captain Tony’s. The attentive staff adds to the overall welcoming atmosphere, making every visitor feel like a local.
  • Historical Artifacts: The bar doesn’t shy away from its storied past. As mentioned in an article by PubClub, historical artifacts are scattered throughout the saloon, adding another layer to its unique charm.

The atmosphere at Captain Tony’s Saloon is a testament to its rich history and vibrant culture. It’s more than just a bar – it’s a living museum, a music venue, and a gathering place for those seeking a slice of authentic Key West.

The Drinks and Food

Stepping into Captain Tony’s Saloon, you’re not just walking into a bar with a rich history, but also a place known for its variety of drinks and unique food offerings. As noted by Florida Beach Bar, the saloon is particularly famous for its Pirates Punch, a drink that has been enjoyed by locals and tourists alike over the years.

  • Pirates Punch: This signature drink, as per Florida Beach Bar, is a must-try for anyone visiting the saloon. While the exact recipe remains a secret, it’s known for its refreshing taste that perfectly complements the lively atmosphere of the bar.
  • Bloody Mary: According to the Saloon’s Full Menu, their Bloody Mary is a classic concoction of vodka, tomato juice, Worcestershire sauce, hot sauces, garlic, herbs, horseradish, celery, olives, salt, and black pepper. It’s a flavorful mix that packs a punch and is a favorite among patrons.
  • Great Service and Reasonably Priced Drinks: As mentioned on Yelp, the bar is known for its great service and reasonably priced drinks. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, you’re sure to enjoy your time at Captain Tony’s Saloon.

While the Saloon doesn’t serve food, its Nachos with Grilled Chicken are quite popular according to their Full Menu. Topped with refried beans, melted cheese, jalapenos, Salsa Mexicana, and Captain Tony’s famous Guacamole, it’s a delicious treat that pairs perfectly with their range of drinks.

Famous Patrons and Ghost Stories

Captain Tony’s Saloon, a notable watering hole in Key West, has been a favorite spot for many famous personalities over the years. As noted by Wikipedia, Ernest Hemingway and Jimmy Buffet are among those who’ve left their mark on this iconic establishment. The barstools at Captain Tony’s are painted with the names of these famed patrons, serving as a testament to the saloon’s rich history and its enduring appeal among both locals and celebrities alike.

In addition to its reputation as a popular hangout, Captain Tony’s Saloon is also known for its intriguing ghost stories. According to Ghosts and Gravestones, the saloon’s past as an ice house and morgue in the 1850s has given rise to several tales of murder, mystery, and a bit of mayhem. These stories add an extra layer of intrigue to the already captivating history of the saloon, making it a must-visit spot for anyone interested in the supernatural.

From the tales of famous patrons like Hemingway and Buffet to the chilling ghost stories, Captain Tony’s Saloon offers a unique blend of history, culture, and mystery. Whether you’re a fan of literature, music, or the paranormal, there’s something at Captain Tony’s Saloon that’s sure to pique your interest. As such, it continues to be a beloved part of Key West’s vibrant heritage, offering visitors a chance to experience a piece of the town’s colorful past.

Why Captain Tony’s Saloon is a Must-Visit

There’s no shortage of unique and inviting bars in Florida, but Captain Tony’s Saloon in Key West stands out for several reasons. Known for its rich history, famous patrons, and intriguing ghost stories, this iconic establishment offers a distinctive experience that sets it apart from the rest.

  • Historical Significance: As per the Saloon’s History, the bar has been a fixture in Key West since 1851. It’s not just a bar, but an integral part of the town’s history, having played host to many notable personalities over the years.
  • Famous Patrons: The likes of Ernest Hemingway and Jimmy Buffet have patronized the saloon, as mentioned on Wikipedia. This connection to celebrities adds an extra layer of appeal to the bar.
  • Unique Atmosphere: The saloon is renowned for its unique atmosphere. As noted by a TripAdvisor review, it embodies all the characteristics of a good dive bar – a rich history, strong drinks, live bands, and a great location.
  • Ghost Stories: The saloon’s past as an ice house and morgue has given rise to several ghost stories, as mentioned by Ghosts and Gravestones. These tales add an extra element of intrigue, making it a must-visit for fans of the supernatural.

Visiting Captain Tony’s Saloon is like taking a step back in time, offering a unique blend of history, culture, and mystery that is hard to find elsewhere. Whether you’re a history buff, a fan of the supernatural, or just someone looking for a good drink, Captain Tony’s Saloon is a must-visit when in Florida.

A Toast to Captain Tony’s Saloon

Captain Tony’s Saloon is more than just a bar; it’s a living piece of Florida’s history. From its historical significance as a fixture in Key West since 1851 to its famed patrons like Ernest Hemingway and Jimmy Buffet, the Saloon has an undeniable charm and appeal.

Its unique atmosphere, complete with strong drinks and live bands, makes it a standout among other bars. And let’s not forget the ghost stories, adding a layer of intrigue that makes every visit memorable.

So, why not add Captain Tony’s Saloon to your itinerary? Experience the rich history, enjoy a Pirates Punch or Bloody Mary, and maybe even encounter a ghost or two. After all, it’s not just about the drink; it’s about the experience. Here’s to making memories at Captain Tony’s Saloon!

Leave a Reply